“There could be other victims, we have not completed our search,” Connelly said. “The buildings are not yet safe to enter.”
The initial survey shows that 39 houses have suffered “severe to minor damage,” the chief added.
The chief later told reporters that 11 of those 39 homes were left uninhabitable, adding that the American Red Cross will be helping those affected families.
Evansville is about 3 hours southwest of Indianapolis.
“I’d seen photos that have been posted online, but once I walked up to the residence itself and saw the devastation with my own eyes, it was, I mean, it was a gut punch,” Winnecke said.
“Across the street from the explosion you’ll see house after house that has windows blown out, that you know there’s insulation blown out from homes,” the mayor added.
A structural collapse team was called in to survey buildings and to make sure that all gas and electric circuits “had integrity,” the chief said.
At least eight agencies were on the scene, including the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives and the State Fire Marshal.
“They will summarize the investigation in the morning,” the chief said at a news conference Wednesday evening. “This is a standard operating procedure for an incident of this magnitude and of this type.”
Search and rescue teams will be allowed back into the area once utilities are secured and the ATF determines their part of the investigation is over, Connelly said.
Authorities also asked residents to stay away from the area.
An investigation of the incident and what caused the explosion is underground, Connelly added.
CNN’s Sara Smart contributed to this story.